Hi TwiFessions, I know what you mean about the shape-shifters, although I'm frustrated because, with the possible exception of Jacob, I don't feel that I know enough about them, so I haven't got an emotional pull towards them.
I also love all the Cullens (most of the time), obviously Edward is my favourite, but from the other Cullens my top 3 are;
#1 Alice – She seems to understand Edward so well and she is ready to accept Bella. She is natural and friendly right from the off.
#2 Carlisle – Now to quote Robward (‘cos they both say this) ‘I dunno errr’…I dunno why I like Carlisle. He has a calming influence on everybody, and he is the authoritative figure in the family, so I have a respect for him – think I’m channelling Bella!
#3 Jasper – I posted about Jasper in the ‘What’s the deal with Jasper, I don’t understand-enlighten me’ thread, so I won’t repeat myself, but it is Jasper’s relationship with Alice that makes me love him… and he is also the most dangerous of the Cullens, ohh err!
On your Rosalie comment, I'm going to create a Rosalie thread 'cos she intrigues me and I would love to hear other peoples thoughts.